Mass Cultural Council logo
Home / Blog / Organizations / Adapting Houses of Worship for Creative Uses

Adapting Houses of Worship for Creative Uses

Jay Paget, Program Director

a photo collage of three houses of worship that have been adapted to also include arts programming - an exterior of a church with people gathers at a festival, a concert rehearsal inside a church building, and young ballet dancers in a studio with high ceilings and dramatic, tall windows behind them.
Houses of worship that have been adapted to include arts programming: (left-to-right) Steeple Playhouse, Bombyx, and José Mateo Ballet Theatre.

Since 2006, Mass Cultural Council has been committed to supporting the development of vibrant creative spaces through technical assistance and the Cultural Facilities Fund. The Agency’s statewide perspective lets us see creative space trends in geographically distant communities with similar stories.

Our series on Adapting Public Buildings for Creative Uses has highlighted municipal buildings that evolved into community art centers:

Now we turn to another kind of building that anchors nearly every community: houses of worship.

In some communities, congregations have dwindled and their capacity to maintain the space has diminished. Yet these marvelous historic buildings are still intact, serving as beautiful community assets but with evidence of deferred maintenance. In these same communities, artists and cultural organizations struggle to find affordable space that can accommodate their programmatic visions where high ceilings, open floor plans, and audience-friendly spaces may be just what they need. Churches have all three.

This most recent case study, Adapting Houses of Worship for Creative Uses, documents three Massachusetts instances where the original congregation still worships in the building, but arts organizations have taken on the primary stewardship role. The arts entity is now either the owner or under a long-term lease agreement and has assumed legal responsibility for the space.

cover of the case study with the text Adapting Houses of Worship for Creative Uses
Download the case study

The evolution to co-habitation is the central focus of this case study. As always, a combination of factors sets the stage for preservation and adaptive reuse of space.

  • José Mateo Ballet Theatre, Cambridge. In 2000, after an 18-month negotiation, the ballet theatre moved into Old Cambridge Baptist Church, an 1870 Gothic Revival landmark in Harvard Square. Six and a half days a week the sanctuary’s 47-foot ceilings house dance classes and performances; on Sunday mornings the congregation worships there. The lease, extended from 20 to 39 years, reinvests half of the rent in the building into capital upkeep.

 Listen to the José Mateo Ballet Theatre Interview >>

  • Bombyx Center for Arts & Equity, Florence. When the aging congregation of the 1861 Florence Congregational Church put its building on the market, it turned down every offer that would have evicted its tenants. Cassandra Holden and her team founded Bombyx with the aim of keeping them all in the space. Today the building is home to the original congregation, the Beit Ahavah synagogue, a preschool that has operated there since 1946, and a busy performance venue. Bombyx began with a memorandum of understanding in 2021 and is now in a 6.5-year lease-to-own agreement.

 Listen to the Bombyx Interview >>

  • Steeple Playhouse, New Bedford. The 1829 First Baptist Church, where the meeting that inspired Robert’s Rules of Order took place, was on the state’s list of most endangered historic resources. The Waterfront Historic Area League (WHALE), Your Theatre, the City of New Bedford, and the congregation spent more than a decade bringing it back into full use.  The building opened as a theater in November 2023, WHALE transferred ownership to Your Theatre in May 2024, and the congregation continues to worship on two floors under a 30-year lease.

 Listen to the Steeple Playhouse Interview >>

This case study walks step by step through how each deal came together: the building assessments, zoning and code changes, financing, and the patient relationship-building with each congregation. Common lessons run through all three: call an architect first; find champions inside both the arts organization and religious community; learn what funding works; and plan for the work to take longer than you expect.

Download the Case Study

Join the Conversation

These case studies are part of Creative Space DNA, a peer network of practitioners led by Mass Cultural Council and the ArtStaysHere Coalition. Each month, people who have preserved, developed, advocated for and operated creative spaces share what they have learned so others don’t have to reinvent the wheel.

More Artist Space Resources


Back to Top